Updated Nov 21, 2026· 9 min read

Key takeaways

  • Compare the best mountain bike cleats for two-bolt shoes: float, single and multi release, and exact pedal system compatibility for SPD riders.

As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.

Our top pick: Shimano SM-SH51 SPD Cleat Set. Runner-up: Shimano SM-SH56 SPD Cleat Set.

Cleats are the smallest part of a clipless setup and the part that wears out first. They decide how much your foot can rotate before it releases, how the shoe engages the pedal, and how secure the connection feels on a steep climb. When a cleat wears down, engagement gets vague and release turns unpredictable. A fresh set restores the crisp entry and dependable exit the pedals were built around.

This guide covers the best mountain bike cleats that can be matched to a verified Amazon listing, and it is honest about what that pool looks like. Every pick below belongs to the Shimano SPD two-bolt family, either as a genuine Shimano cleat or as a third-party cleat built to the SPD pattern. Riders on Crankbrothers or Time pedals use completely different cleats, and the buying guide explains why those systems never mix, so nobody orders the wrong part.

Buying Guide: Systems, Float and Release

Pedal systems are not cross-compatible

All five picks bolt to the same two-hole pattern found on mountain bike shoes, but two-bolt mounting does not mean universal fit at the pedal. Shimano SPD cleats only engage Shimano SPD pedals. Crankbrothers pedals need Crankbrothers brass cleats, and the maker states plainly that SPD cleats will not work in its pedals. Time ATAC pedals need Time ATAC cleats. The shoe is shared across systems; the cleat is not. Match the cleat to the pedal brand first, and only then compare float and release.

Float: how much rotation you get

Float is the number of degrees your heel can rotate while clipped in before the cleat starts to release. Both genuine Shimano cleats in this guide list 4 degrees of float, which gives the knee a small amount of natural movement without making the connection feel loose. Riders with sensitive knees usually prefer more float rather than less. Float is set by the cleat model, so it is a buying decision, not an adjustment you make later.

Single release vs multi release

Shimano sells two release behaviours. Single-release cleats, the SM-SH51 pattern, come out only when you twist your heel outward, which keeps the shoe held firmly during hard pulling and sprinting. Multi-release cleats, the SM-SH56 pattern, also release when you lift and twist the heel, so they suit riders learning clipless or dabbing a foot often on technical ground. Both list the same 13-degree clip-out angle. The third-party cleats below follow the single-release pattern unless the listing says otherwise.

Material, wear and hardware

Shimano builds its cleats from steel, and Shimano’s own product copy describes the SM-SH51 as heat treated forged steel made to keep engagement consistent as it wears. Third-party cleats use their own steels, and one pick below uses molybdenum steel. Cleats are a wear item by design: they are softer than the pedal mechanism so the cleat sacrifices itself first. Check the bolts every few rides, keep the cleat and pedal faces clear of packed mud, and replace the set when entry starts to feel mushy. Some sets include spacers or walking wings, which help when deep shoe tread holds the cleat away from the pedal.

The 5 Best Mountain Bike Cleats

1. Shimano SM-SH51 SPD Cleat Set

The SM-SH51 is the standard Shimano SPD cleat and the one supplied with most Shimano SPD pedals, which makes this set the default replacement for the largest group of mountain bikers. It uses single-direction release: the cleat only lets go when the heel twists outward, so the shoe stays planted when you pull up hard or sprint out of the saddle. Shimano lists 4 degrees of float and a 13-degree clip-out angle, a combination that holds the foot securely while allowing a small amount of knee-friendly rotation.

This particular listing is the version packaged with a 4mm Allen wrench, so the tool needed for the two mounting bolts is in the box. Shimano describes the cleat as heat treated forged steel, built for long service in mud and grit, and the two-bolt pattern fits any mountain bike shoe with the standard recessed cleat box. It is not compatible with the old PD-M858 pedal, and it does not fit SPD-SL road pedals, a separate three-bolt system. For riders whose pedals came with SH51 cleats and who want the same feel again, this is the straightforward like-for-like swap.

Specs

  • Pedal system: Shimano SPD, two-bolt
  • Release mode: Single direction, heel outward
  • Float: 4 degrees
  • Clip-out angle: 13 degrees
  • Model number: ISMSH51AJ
  • Included: Cleat pair and 4mm Allen wrench
  • ASIN: B07JGSM12J

2. Shimano SM-SH56 SPD Cleat Set

The SM-SH56 uses the same SPD interface as the SH51 but changes the release behaviour to multi-directional. As Shimano’s listing copy puts it, the cleat releases by twisting the foot in either direction or by lifting and twisting the heel, so a rider can get out with a less precise movement. That makes the SH56 the common recommendation for riders new to clipless pedals, riders with limited knee mobility, and anyone who wants an easier exit on slow technical climbs.

The numbers otherwise match the SH51: 4 degrees of float and a 13-degree clip-out angle, in a cold forged, heat treated steel cleat that fits nearly all Shimano SPD pedals. The trade-off is retention. Because the cleat can release with an upward twist, aggressive riders who pull hard on the pedals may prefer the single-release SH51. Many riders keep an SH56 set on the shoes they use for learning new skills and an SH51 set for racing or steep terrain.

Specs

  • Pedal system: Shimano SPD, two-bolt
  • Release mode: Multi-directional
  • Float: 4 degrees
  • Clip-out angle: 13 degrees
  • Model number: ISMSH56
  • ASIN: B0C21NM9FP

3. CyclingDeal 98R Bike Cleats

CyclingDeal’s 98R cleat set is a third-party option built to the Shimano SPD SM-SH51 pattern, sold for Shimano MTB SPD pedals and aimed at both indoor cycling and mountain bike shoes. It follows the single-release behaviour of the SH51, so it suits riders who want the standard secure hold rather than the easier multi-release exit. The cleats are made from molybdenum steel according to the listing, and the set adds one feature the genuine Shimano sets do not list: walking adapter wings.

Those wings sit around the cleat to give the shoe a flatter, steadier platform on hard surfaces, which matters for riders who walk through cafes, offices or gym floors on the same shoes they ride in. Because this is a compatibility cleat rather than a genuine Shimano part, check the listing’s stated fit against your exact pedal model before ordering, and expect the engagement feel to be close to, rather than identical to, the Shimano original it is patterned on.

Specs

  • Pedal compatibility: Shimano SPD pedals, SM-SH51 pattern
  • Release mode: Single release
  • Material: Molybdenum steel
  • Part number: 98R
  • Included: Cleat pair with walking adapter wings
  • ASIN: B07WH4TMQX

4. BV Bike Cleats BV-CT-01-SPD

BV’s cleat set covers two pedal families in one product: the listing states compatibility with Shimano SPD pedals and with Look X-Track pedals, which makes it useful for riders whose household runs both systems. Look’s X-Track is Look’s own two-bolt mountain system, so a cleat the maker rates for both interfaces fills a gap the single-system sets above do not address. The set is sold as one pair with the mounting screws included.

Guide data drawn from the listing describes a single-direction release and 14 degrees of rotational adjustment when positioning the cleat on the shoe, giving more room to fine-tune cleat angle than fixed-position sets. The cleats are metal, and the listing’s product table lists a package weight of 68.04 grams. As with any dual-compatibility claim, confirm the exact pedal model on the listing page before buying, since X-Track and SPD are separate systems with their own genuine cleats.

Specs

  • Pedal compatibility: Shimano SPD and Look X-Track, per listing
  • Release mode: Single direction
  • Model number: BV-CT-01-SPD
  • Included: Bike cleats and screws
  • UPC: 813076021820
  • ASIN: B07BRDVJ5J

5. Autotide SPD Cleats for SM-SH51 and SM-SH56

This set is the value pick of the group: a stainless steel cleat pair with an anti-slip rubber element, built for Shimano SPD pedals in the SM-SH51 and SM-SH56 pattern. The product record lists a complete fitting kit in the box, with two cleats, two spacers, four screws and a wrench. The spacers matter more than they might seem: on shoes with deep tread, a spacer lifts the cleat enough for it to engage the pedal cleanly instead of being held off by the sole.

The record lists the set at 150 grams and gives dimensions of 5 by 5 by 1.5 centimetres, and the anti-slip rubber calms the metal-on-hard-floor skating that plain steel cleats can produce when you walk. The listing does not state a float figure or a release mode of its own; it is patterned on the SH51 and SH56 interface, so confirm the details on the product page. For a spare set in the toolbox or a second pair of shoes, the complete hardware kit is the appeal.

Specs

  • Pedal compatibility: Shimano SPD, SM-SH51 and SM-SH56 pattern
  • Material: Stainless steel with anti-slip rubber
  • Included: 2 cleats, 2 spacers, 4 screws, 1 wrench
  • Weight: 150 g per the product record
  • ASIN: B0GDZYXR4J

Key Factors Before You Buy

Match the system, not the shoe. Every cleat here fits a two-bolt shoe, but the pedal decides the cleat. SPD cleats for SPD pedals, Crankbrothers cleats for Crankbrothers pedals, ATAC cleats for Time pedals.

Choose the release you actually need. Single release holds harder and suits experienced riders; multi release exits more easily and suits learners and technical riders who dab often.

Replace cleats in pairs and early. A worn cleat changes release on both sides of your riding, from entry feel to emergency exits. When one side looks thin or hooked, change both.

Use the hardware in the box. Spacers and correct bolt length keep the cleat seated at the right height. A cleat sitting too low in deep tread will not engage properly no matter how new it is.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I use SPD cleats in Crankbrothers or Time pedals?

No. All three systems share the same two-bolt shoe mounting, but the cleat shapes and pedal mechanisms are different and are not cross-compatible. Crankbrothers states that SPD cleats will not work with its pedals, and Time ATAC pedals require ATAC cleats.

What is the difference between the SH51 and SH56 cleats?

The interface, float and clip-out angle are the same: both are Shimano SPD cleats with 4 degrees of float and a 13-degree clip-out angle. The difference is release. The SH51 releases in a single direction, by twisting the heel outward. The SH56 is multi-directional and also releases when you lift and twist the heel, which makes it easier to exit.

How do I know when my cleats need replacing?

Watch for vague or inconsistent release, entry that takes several attempts, or visible thinning and hooking of the cleat’s engagement edges. Brass cleats in the Crankbrothers and Time systems wear faster than steel SPD cleats by design, since the cleat is meant to wear before the pedal does.

Do third-party SPD cleats work as well as genuine Shimano cleats?

They fit the same pedals and shoes, and the sets above state their compatibility and materials in their listings. Engagement feel can differ slightly from the genuine part because tolerances and steel grades vary, so riders who want the exact original feel should choose the Shimano SH51 or SH56, while the third-party sets add extras such as walking wings, spacers or dual-system compatibility.

Conclusion

For most mountain bikers, the genuine Shimano cleats are the safe centre of this category: the SM-SH51 for a secure single-release hold, and the SM-SH56 when an easier multi-directional exit matters more. The third-party sets earn their place around those two, with the CyclingDeal 98R adding walking wings, the BV set covering both SPD and Look X-Track pedals, and the Autotide kit packing spacers and a wrench into a complete spare set. Keep the governing rule in front of you: the cleat belongs to the pedal system, not the shoe.

M
Mike Sullivan
We compare specs, materials and verified owner reviews before a product earns a spot. Rankings are never paid.

FAQ

Can I use SPD cleats in Crankbrothers or Time pedals?
No. All three systems share the same two-bolt shoe mounting, but the cleat shapes and pedal mechanisms are different and are not cross-compatible. Crankbrothers states that SPD cleats will not work with its pedals, and Time ATAC pedals require ATAC cleats.
What is the difference between the SH51 and SH56 cleats?
The interface, float and clip-out angle are the same: both are Shimano SPD cleats with 4 degrees of float and a 13-degree clip-out angle. The difference is release. The SH51 releases in a single direction, by twisting the heel outward. The SH56 is multi-directional and also releases when you lift and twist the heel, which makes it easier to exit.
How do I know when my cleats need replacing?
Watch for vague or inconsistent release, entry that takes several attempts, or visible thinning and hooking of the cleat’s engagement edges. Brass cleats in the Crankbrothers and Time systems wear faster than steel SPD cleats by design, since the cleat is meant to wear before the pedal does.
Do third-party SPD cleats work as well as genuine Shimano cleats?
They fit the same pedals and shoes, and the sets above state their compatibility and materials in their listings. Engagement feel can differ slightly from the genuine part because tolerances and steel grades vary, so riders who want the exact original feel should choose the Shimano SH51 or SH56, while the third-party sets add extras such as walking wings, spacers or dual-system compatibility.
Affiliate disclosure. As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you. Prices accurate as of the date shown.
Best Mountain Bike Cleats: Top Gear Picks For…Check price on Amazon

More from Amazon

Programs that pair well with the guide above. Offers and eligibility are set by Amazon and may change.

Amazon Prime

Free shipping on eligible items, Prime Video and more. Eligible new members can start with a free trial.

Start a Prime free trial
Prime for Young Adults

A Prime membership for ages 18-24 with a trial period. Eligibility is set by Amazon.

See Prime for Young Adults
Audible

Audiobooks and podcasts to listen to on the go. Eligible new members can start with a free trial.

Try Audible free
Amazon Music Unlimited

Ad-free music streaming. Eligible new subscribers can start with a free trial.

Try Music Unlimited free

As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.